Custer's Last Stand Menu

Custer's Last Stand, nestled at 176 Kingston Ave in Wurtsboro, NY, offers a nostalgic yet vibrant stop for ice cream lovers and casual diners alike. Known for its rich, creamy ice cream and frozen yogurt, the spot also features classic comfort foods like chicken tenders, fries, and burgers. Guests order at the counter and enjoy a laid-back atmosphere with wooden benches, enhancing a simple, welcoming experience.

The generous portion sizes, even in small servings, make it a favorite for families and travelers. While some patrons mention the occasional inconsistency in dessert presentation and slightly steep prices on savory items, the overall quality and indulgent flavors stand out. Whether you're craving a thick milkshake, a loaded ice cream sundae, or a quick bite of fried favorites, Custer's Last Stand delivers hearty satisfaction in a cozy setting. Keep in mind, it's a cash-only venue, adding to its old-school charm.